15 Outstanding Homemade Butter Tart Recipes

The number of butter tart recipes in Canada could fill a book on its own. I mean is there anything more Canadian than Butter Tarts? Every single Canadian Mom or Grandma has butter tart recipes to boast about. In fact butter tarts are one of my favourite desserts. They are even yummier than my second favourite – lemon tarts and desserts. So let’s talk butter tart recipes.


Butter Tart recipes are generally pretty simple to find and if you start to ask around you will see that everybody has an opinion on what kind they love. Soupy, liquid, buttery gooey butter tart recipes are my personal favourite. I am definitely not team walnuts or raisins. Just love them smooth and buttery.


15 Beautiful Homemade Butter Tart Recipes

1. Best Butter Tarts On The Planet
2. Best Classic Canadian Butter Tarts
3. Sugar Free Butter Tarts
4. Classic Butter Tarts
5. Mom’s Best Butter Tarts
6. Genuine Canadian Butter Tarts Without Corn Syrup
7. Gramma’s Butter Tarts
8. Grandma Brown’s Butter Tarts
9. Butter Tarts Recipe
10. Low Carb Butter Tarts
11. Old Fashioned Butter Tarts
12. Butter Tarts
13. Maple Buttertarts
14. Old Fashioned Butter Tarts
15. Butter Tarts

So where do you fall on the topic of butter tarts? Are you team walnuts and or raisins or team simple butter tarts without anything lumpy in them? You can tell my preference easily enough. LOL. Have you ever had butter tarts? Where were the best ones you ever sampled?

These are my personal favourites:



Save the recipe and Pin It for later – > BEST BUTTER TARTS ON THE PLANET

Happy Canada Day!

This post contains affiliate links as a service to my readers, at no extra cost to you. If you make a purchase from this page I receive a small commission. 

Mom of two beautiful active girls, traveller, fitness junkie, social media consultant, and keeper of the sanity.